Please wait...

Valuing a Professional Practice in a South Carolina Divorce

Dentist and financial advisor reviewing practice valuation documents, with a dental treatment room visible in the background.

If you or your spouse owns a dental office, medical practice, law firm, or other professional practice, determining its value can become an important part of divorce.

The practice may own equipment, collect outstanding bills, and generate substantial income. But part of its value may also come from goodwill—the reputation and relationships that keep clients or patients returning.

In South Carolina, whether that goodwill belongs to the business or the individual professional can make a significant difference.

Personal goodwill vs. enterprise goodwill

Personal goodwill depends on the professional’s individual skills, reputation, and relationships. Patients might choose a dentist specifically because they trust that dentist. This goodwill is excluded from equitable distribution.

Enterprise goodwill belongs to the business independently of one person. It may reflect an established organization that can retain customers after the owner leaves. Enterprise goodwill may be included in the marital estate.

In Moore v. Moore (2015), the South Carolina Supreme Court expressly adopted this distinction. The court’s approach requires examining the evidence rather than assuming all goodwill receives the same treatment.

What did Dickert actually decide?

In Dickert v. Dickert (2010), the Supreme Court rejected approximately $256,517 in claimed enterprise goodwill included in the husband’s dental-practice valuation.

That did not mean the entire practice had no divisible value. The court removed the disputed goodwill and sent the equitable-distribution issue back for reconsideration. The decision should not be read as limiting every professional practice to consideration for support purposes alone.

A more recent dental-practice decision

In Bostick v. Bostick (2024), the Supreme Court applied the personal-versus-enterprise distinction to a dental practice that had been sold.

The court found the disputed goodwill was personal to the dentist. Evidence emphasized his professional reputation and patient relationships; no evidence established enterprise goodwill.

Importantly, the spouse seeking to include goodwill in the marital estate bears the burden of proving it is enterprise goodwill. A sale price that includes “goodwill” does not, by itself, establish that the goodwill is divisible.

What information should you gather?

Ask your attorney whether a qualified business valuation expert is needed. Useful records may include:

  • Business tax returns and financial statements.
  • Equipment lists, debts, and accounts receivable.
  • Ownership agreements and purchase or sale documents.
  • Information about other professionals working in the practice.
  • Evidence showing whether clients or patients would remain if the owner left.

For a broader explanation, read Settlyd’s guide to dividing a business in a South Carolina divorce.

Once reliable values are available, Settlyd’s side-by-side worksheets can help you and your attorney compare settlement options.

The key question is not simply, “What is the practice worth?” It is also, “Which parts of that value can legally be divided?”

Sources

  1. Dickert v. Dickert (2010) โ€” South Carolina Supreme Court (2026-11-05)
  2. Moore v. Moore (2015) โ€” South Carolina Supreme Court (2026-11-05)
  3. Bostick v. Bostick (2024) โ€” South Carolina Supreme Court (2026-11-05)